Your toolbox talks are going to differ when it comes to Residential Construction vs commercial construction. Make sure you have the right construction app to handle it.
When it comes to toolbox talks and safety, there are major differences between Residential Construction and Commercial Construction.
A safety talk for residential construction may remind workers to be careful (and aware) with a nail gun around bricklayers, while a safety talk for commercial construction may focus on fall protection equipment, safety harnesses, and guardrails.
Either way, the paper safety toolbox talk form template you’re using might be completely irrelevant. You’re fumbling through questions and the workers are getting agitated as you’re wasting daylight.
Sound about right?
What do our construction site users and construction business app users say?
We know construction mobile forms apps work, because we surveyed over 50 construction site professionals and 50% said they wanted to increase site safety and a streamlined health & safety system with our platform.
To ensure enterprise-level safety and scale your safety talks in minutes, our customers use a drag-and-drop construction mobile forms app they build themselves. And it works – just look at our mobile forms and business apps case studies!
In the construction world, utilising mobile forms and low-code/no-code construction apps is the smart move. These digital tools make communication and collaboration a breeze, all while cutting down on that tedious paperwork.
Simply whip out your smartphone or tablet and get things done! You’ll save time, money, and contribute to eco-friendly practices while you’re at it, too. You may also save lives with access to Mobile BI on site.
Create a toolbox talk relevant to your construction team
But are you creating the right toolbox talk for your needs? Are you using paper forms that take hours to build? Are you asking the right questions and discussing the correct safety topics?
If you’re a site safety officer, project manager or supervisor, you know Toolbox talks are an essential component of construction site safety. These short, informal discussions aim to keep workers informed about potential hazards and safe work practices. While both residential and commercial construction firms obviously benefit from toolbox talks, there are some differences in how these talks are conducted based on project types, workforce size, and specific safety hazards and regulations.
In this article, we’ll look at the differences in toolbox talks for residential construction vs commercial construction.
Disclaimer: yes I know you can have commercial residential construction, but for this article we’ll reference commercial i.e. high rises, multi-site construction, and residential as home renovation, new-build construction etc.
Differences Between Toolbox Talks and Safety For Residential vs Commercial Construction
Difference #1 – Workforce Size
Residential construction firms often have smaller workforces with less diversity in terms of job roles. This may result in a narrower scope and fewer toolbox talks on a weekly basis, focusing on more general safety training, job scheduling and JHA checks. If it’s a small team, you may not need geolocation or lone worker protection.
On the other hand, commercial construction firms typically have larger and more diverse teams, requiring specialised toolbox talks to address the unique safety concerns of each worker or team. Sites will often have siloed teams for plumbing, heating, welding, electricity etc. However, you’ll still likely need JHA checks too! But you may need geolocation weather checks for multi-site operations.
Your toolbox talks will differ based on workforce size.
Let’s look at some real-world examples of differences.
Real-world example #1
It takes care of scheduling and tracking these crucial discussions for you. But this business app will differ depending on where you;re using it. Let’s dig deeper on the two different examples.
For instance, if you’re using a project management app, your construction mobile app sends out a weekly/daily toolbox talk topic and a related safety checklist to all your supervisors.
This checklist could have something like a lone worker protection check, which asks your workers to verify they’re following the right safety procedures when working solo, such as using the buddy system or regularly checking in with a designated contact, or acknowledging automated check-in through the app. The supervisor can discuss the dangers of working alone, then ping this out to specific members of your crew.
Thanks to this automation, you’re making sure everyone gets consistent safety reminders. Plus, the mobile forms app uses skip logic to personalise the toolbox talk content based on each worker’s specific job role, keeping the info on point and engaging.
If you’re operating smaller projects, garden homes or renovation projects for residential construction, you may need different styles of toolbox talks that discuss any potential electrical hazards, weather issues (if you’re working outside) or potential sewage or mould problems. You’ll likely not need LWP checks. With a paperless toolbox talk, you can skip this easily.
This leads me to my next point…
Difference #2 – Project Types
Residential construction projects usually involve smaller-scale renovations, repairs, or can also involve new build projects. As such, the safety hazards encountered may differ from those in commercial construction, where large-scale infrastructure, high-rise buildings, or complex structures are common.
Toolbox talks in residential construction might focus more on general safety precautions, like where to dig, where NOT to dig, who’s using the nail gun and where etc. while commercial construction talks could delve into specific hazards and regulations relevant to larger projects.
Real-world example #2:
For instance, your construction project management app could have a safety checklist that includes a “Digging Safely” section (just an example – you can call it what you want!) with clear instructions and a visual map of the work site to avoid utility lines or pipes complete with images of the area taken by the surveyor.
Your team can quickly access this info on their mobile devices, ensuring they know exactly what they’re dealing with. You can then deliver access to these images via push notifications. This way, you’re keeping safety talks relevant and efficient for your residential construction team.
Now let’s consider a commercial construction project, which involves larger-scale infrastructure, high-rise buildings, or complex structures. The safety hazards and regulations in this scenario are obviously way more complex and require specialised toolbox talks tailored to the unique challenges of commercial construction.
With a mobile construction forms app, you can easily create custom toolbox talks addressing those specific safety hazards and regulations relevant to commercial construction projects.
For instance, you might have a toolbox talk focused on working at heights, covering the proper use of fall protection equipment, safety harnesses, and guardrails. Another talk could tackle safe operation of heavy machinery, like cranes and excavators, outlining pre-operational checks, load limits, and communication protocols among the team.
Again, this is all part of giving a good toolbox talk! Because you’ve made it relevant to your teams, sites, and your company.
The low-code/no-code construction mobile forms app can also help manage and track certifications and training for specialised roles, ensuring that all workers are qualified for their tasks and are legally allowed to be there. By leveraging a mobile forms app, you’re making sure that your commercial construction team receives targeted and up-to-date safety information, enabling them to work efficiently and safely on large-scale projects.
Your team knows what they’re doing, how to do it and are qualified to be there. You’ve delivered the toolbox talk in minutes, specific to the team. This is a huge benefit of digital toolbox talks in Construction!
Difference #3 – Regulation Safety Differences Between Residential & Commercial Construction
About 30% of construction mobile app customers researched, showed that compliance was a main reason for using mobile construction forms on the forms2 platform.
It makes total sense.
Depending on the jurisdiction and project type, residential and commercial construction firms may need to comply with different safety regulations and standards, something we’ve covered in our Disadvantages of Toolbox talks blog.
For example, commercial construction firms might face more stringent regulations around fire safety, emergency exits, and accessibility compared to residential construction firms and garden office firms. Even if you run a small operation, you are legally required to provide safety training! Which will include toolbox talks.
In the UK, The Health and Safety at Work etc. Act is what you need to follow in terms of safety at work. It applies to all workplaces, all employees and all employers.
In the USA, you’ll likely be following OSHA requirements, so make sure you check ahead of time.
Two things to consider…
It goes without saying that these regulatory differences should be reflected in the content and frequency of toolbox talks to ensure compliance. It also goes without saying that you should only work with compliant, qualified workers.
Fortunately, you can set up your construction mobile app to access proof of JHA’s and ensure you only work with preferred contractors with proof of CSCS, CSCS Affiliated Schemes (or equivalent)!
You can also set up your construction mobile forms app to access up-to-date safety protocols as required by OSHA, and HSE for example, in your hand, automatically updated by the back office ahead of the meeting. If you need to keep up with regulations on a day-to-day basis, this is a sign you need a low-code/no-code business app!
Residential Construction regulation examples
Here’s a real-world example of how regulations discussed in construction toolbox talks can ensure the success of a build:
In residential construction, local building codes often dictate specific requirements for electrical wiring, plumbing, and structural components. Your mobile forms app can be set up to include these local building code requirements, allowing workers to quickly reference and confirm their work complies with the regulations and take pictures from their phone for proof.
This helps to avoid costly mistakes and ensures the safety and quality of the finished project, while making sure you’re legally covered/insured.
Commercial Construction Regulation Example In A Digital Toolbox Talk
Here’s a real-world example of how a construction mobile forms app can make it easier for commercial construction firms to stay compliant with fire safety regulations.
For instance, a mobile forms and data capture app can be used to create a fire safety checklist, ensuring that all necessary fire protection measures are in place, such as functioning fire alarms, extinguishers, and clearly marked emergency exits – mobile data capture apps are perfect for property developers and even facility managers too!
Again, you can set your app to also include specific regulatory requirements from OSHA or HSE, ensuring that your team is always aware of the most up-to-date fire safety guidelines and you’re covered, legally.
Difference #4 – Tools and Equipment
The tools and equipment used in residential construction will often differ from those in commercial construction.
Residential projects may involve more hand tools and manual labour, while commercial projects could require heavy machinery and power tools, along with added safety protocols.
On a commercial build, you’ll want to tell your team to wear hearing protection, on a residential build, you might just want to tell Steve to take it easy with the nail gun around the bricklayers.
Toolbox talks should address the unique safety considerations associated with each sector’s specific tools and equipment.
This is another reason you should use a mobile data capture app for construction and an example of the benefit of digital toolbox talks for construction, as you can use pre-built templates and drag and drop them using our low-code/no-code app builder depending on the site and what tools are being used.
Benefits of Paperless Toolbox Talks for Both Residential and Commercial Construction Firms
Regardless of the differences between residential and commercial construction, both industries can benefit from paperless toolbox talks. By adopting digital solutions for toolbox talks, construction firms can improve safety and hazard awareness, enhance communication among team members, and increase efficiency in delivering and documenting these essential safety discussions. All while promoting citizen development in their firm and retaining staff!
In a nutshell, they make construction go a lot smoother and you can write toolbox talks faster!
Build your construction mobile forms app, in minutes NOT weeks
So, as you can see, it’s super important to tailor your toolbox talks to the unique needs of both residential and commercial construction. By keeping in mind things like workforce size, project types, regulations, and tools and equipment, you’ll be able to create toolbox talks that are not only relevant but actually effective!
And hey, why not take it a step further and go paperless?
Switching to paperless toolbox talks and building a construction mobile forms app with forms2 can make a world of difference in terms of safety, communication, and efficiency on the job site. Trust us, both residential and commercial construction firms will see the benefits and you can see so in our mobile forms and business apps case studies / testimonials.
Are you ready to handle your toolbox talks and site inspections in half the time? Sign up for a free trial today and start building your own construction mobile forms and data capture app in minutes!
The easiest mobile form builder for the construction industry
14-day free trial
Did you know that access to Mobile BI can actually save your workers’ lives, too?